Flat organic traffic used to be a clear warning sign. Today, it can be a symptom of a healthier, more revenue-focused SEO program—if you know where to look. Recent coverage from Search Engine Land highlights why traditional traffic metrics are losing signal and how teams should reframe success for AI-driven search results.
Why a flat line on your traffic chart can be misleading
As Adam Heitzman wrote for Search Engine Land, “flat traffic doesn’t mean failure anymore.” Heitzman points to AI Overviews—Google’s synthesized answers on the SERP—as a major factor: they provide users with answers without requiring a click, creating attribution gaps that make organic performance look worse than its business impact.
The practical effect is straightforward: content that powers AI Overviews can drive brand awareness and downstream conversions that never show up as direct organic clicks. Heitzman explains that teams seeing steady sessions but stronger conversion metrics are often experiencing precisely this dynamic: fewer raw clicks, better business outcomes.
Key takeaways from the reporting
1) Traffic is an incomplete KPI
Traffic volume no longer captures the full value of organic. Instead, track revenue per visitor, branded search lift, and assisted conversions alongside sessions to see the full funnel impact of SEO work.
2) AI Overviews and zero-click behavior are real and measurable
Industry studies confirm the scale of the change. Seer Interactive’s analysis found that “the organic CTR for queries with AIOs has been cut by nearly two-thirds,” and that queries with AI Overviews now deliver dramatically fewer clicks than they once did. That doesn’t mean the content fails; it means the content is increasingly consumed inside the search interface.
3) Optimize for business outcomes, not vanity metrics
Shifting to middle- and bottom-funnel keywords—pricing, comparisons, and transactional queries—can preserve click opportunities while delivering higher-intent traffic. But if your content is being cited by AI Overviews, measuring share of voice in those features should become part of your visibility playbook.
What this means for reporting and measurement
Start by expanding your dashboards. Include:
- Revenue per visitor (RPV) and organic cost per acquisition
- Branded search volume and direct traffic trends
- Assisted conversion paths that begin with organic search
- Share of voice in AI citations and featured snippets (using tools that track AIO presence)
Combine those metrics into an executive narrative that starts with business outcomes. Instead of opening a report with sessions, lead with revenue, qualified leads, and conversion rate changes attributable to organic initiatives.
Actionable strategy recommendations
Prioritize citation and authority
Seer’s findings suggest that being cited in an AI Overview materially improves click performance when compared to uncited results. Invest in authoritative, well-structured content, schema markup, and source-level trust signals so Google’s models have reason to cite your pages.
Target for intent
Shift some content and paid investment toward MOFU and BOFU queries where AI Overviews are less common and conversion intent is higher—terms like “[product] pricing,” “[product] vs [competitor],” and “best [product] for [use case].” These produce fewer visits but much higher value per visitor.
Integrate measurement across channels
Coordinate SEO with PR, paid, and direct-response channels. If AI Overviews increase brand exposure without clicks, you need mechanisms—UTM strategies, brand lift tests, and multi-touch attribution—to capture downstream effects and assign value.
When flat traffic is still a problem
Not all flat traffic is positive. Heitzman warns that flat or declining traffic paired with falling conversions, worsening engagement metrics, or broad ranking declines still signals trouble. Use segmented landing-page and keyword analysis to distinguish healthy quality shifts from genuine loss of relevance.
Final thoughts
Search behavior has changed, and so must SEO reporting and strategy. Flat traffic can be the visible sign of a deeper win: more qualified visitors, better conversion efficiency, and valuable brand exposure inside AI-powered results. But those wins only show up if you measure them the right way.
For a deeper look at the original reporting, see the Search Engine Land piece by Adam Heitzman and Seer Interactive’s analysis of AI Overviews and CTR trends.
Sources: Adam Heitzman, Search Engine Land: https://searchengineland.com/explain-flat-traffic-seo-467757
Seer Interactive: https://www.seerinteractive.com/insights/aio-impact-on-google-ctr-september-2025-update
.png)
